A world-first survey of thousands of Australian doctors and medical students has revealed they are burnt-out, more likely to experience psychological distress and suicidal thoughts than the general community and are drinking too much alcohol.
beyondblue’s National Mental Health Survey of Doctors and Medical Students found that medical students and young or female doctors are most at risk and identified that significant levels of stigma towards people with mental health problems. Some respondents also reported that they were bullied or experienced racism.
beyondblue Chairman The Hon. Jeff Kennett AC said the findings revealed the extent of doctors’ and medical students suffering and should act as an immediate rallying call for action.
“We conducted this survey because, given doctors and medical students are under immense pressure and deal regularly with pain and death, we know that the mental health of many of them is poor,” he said.
“This survey builds on our previous work in this area and we hope it also serves as a wake-up call to the Australian medical community that more must be done to tackle things such as over-work and discriminatory attitudes.”
beyondblue CEO Kate Carnell AO said more must be done not only to help doctors and students, but also patients.
“If doctors do not deal with the mental health issues they are experiencing, it can affect their ability to deliver the best care,” she said.
“This survey identifies the challenges the medical community faces and outlines how they can be tackled.
"This includes initiatives such as the development of a mental health strategy for the Australian medical community to promote good mental health, the development of guidelines around working hours, better mental health education in universities to reduce stigma, and awareness campaigns.
"We know doctors are distressed and think a lot about suicide, yet this survey indicates they are diagnosed with depression and anxiety at equal or lesser rates than the community.
"Given the high levels of stigma among doctors revealed by this survey, we think doctors are reluctant to admit they have a mental health problem, further highlighting the need for action.
"The survey also shows some doctors experience bullying and racism, which is completely unacceptable.
"I encourage all medical workplaces to investigate how to create a mentally healthy workplace, starting with a visit to www.beyondblue.org.au/workplace.”
The survey, which was conducted by Roy Morgan and completed by more than 14,000 doctors and medical students, is believed to be the first anywhere in the world to provide a mental health snapshot of such a large proportion of a country’s medical community.
Read the executive summary
Read the final report
Some major findings include:
- One in five medical students and one in 10 doctors had suicidal thoughts in the past year, compared with one in 45 people in the wider community, according to the report. More than four in 10 students and a quarter of doctors are highly likely to have a minor psychiatric disorder, like mild depression or mild anxiety
- 3.4% of doctors are experiencing very high psychological distress, much greater than the wider community
- Oncologists are clearly the most psychologically distressed specialists while doctors who do not deal with patients (researchers, administrators, etc) think about suicide most often
- Male doctors work longer hours (46 per week) and engage in more risky drinking but female doctors are more psychologically distressed and think about suicide more often
- Young doctors work longer hours (50 per week on average), are far more psychologically distressed, think about suicide more and are more burnt-out than their older colleagues
- Perceived stigma is rife with almost half of respondents thinking doctors are less likely to appoint doctors with a history of depression or anxiety and four in 10 agreeing that many doctors think less of doctors who have experienced depression or anxiety. 4.5% list bullying and 1.7% list racism as a cause of stress for them.
Available for interview: Mr Kennett, Ms Carnell, former Australian Medical Association president and Chair of beyondblue’s advisory committee Dr Mukesh Haikerwal AO and doctors who have experienced depression.
A selection of major findings from the report
Please note: Refer to the full report for details. All mean scores refer to the survey's findings unless otherwise stated.
In tables that list doctors by specialty, data provided by doctors who did not list their specialty have not been included.
Percentage of doctors by specialty who are highly likely to have a minor psychiatric disorder
| Doctor by specialty ||% |
|Paediatrics ||31.8 |
|Non-patient ||30.9 |
|Anaesthetics ||29.5 |
|Imaging and pathology ||28.4 |
|Emergency medicine ||27.5 |
|Other ||26.7 |
|Rural/remote medicine or Aboriginal health ||26.0 |
|General practitioner ||24.9 |
|Obstetrics and gynaecology ||24.7 |
|Mental health ||24.3 |
|Surgery ||20.5 |
|Mean ||27.2 |
Percentage of doctors by specialty who are experiencing very high psychological distress
| Doctor by specialty ||% |
|Oncology ||5.5 |
|Anaesthetics ||3.8 |
|Imaging and pathology ||3.6 |
|Obstetrics and gynaecology ||3.4 |
|Non-patient ||3.3 |
|Paediatrics ||3.3 |
|Other ||3.1 |
|Emergency medicine ||2.9 |
|General practitioner ||2.9 |
|Surgery ||2.5 |
|Mental health ||2.3 |
|Rural/remote medicine or Aboriginal health ||1.7 |
|Mean ||3.4 |
Working hours by specialty, mean hours worked per week
| Doctor by specialty || hours |
|Rural/remote medicine or Aboriginal health || 50.9 |
|Surgery || 50.8 |
|Obstetrics and gynaecology || 48.3 |
|Oncology || 47.6 |
|Other || 45.4 |
|Paediatrics ||45.3 |
|Anaesthetics ||43.8 |
|Emergency medicine || 42.9 |
|Imaging and pathology || 42.9 |
|Mental health || 41.3 |
|Non-patient || 41.0 |
|General practitioner || 39.9 |
|Mean || 43.6 |
Percentage of doctors by specialty who drink at moderate risk levels
| Doctors by specialty || % |
|Emergency medicine ||17.2 |
|Surgery ||15.5 |
|Anaesthetics ||15.4 |
|Rural/remote medicine or Aboriginal health ||12.5 |
|Other ||11.8 |
|General practitioner ||11.7 |
|Obstetrics and gynaecology ||11.7 |
|Paediatrics ||11.7 |
|Non-patient ||11.0 |
|Mental health ||10.9 |
|Imaging and pathology ||10.3 |
|Oncology ||9.1 |
|Mean ||12.8 |
Percentage of doctors by specialty who drink at high risk or harmful levels
| Doctors by specialty || % |
|Rural/remote medicine or Aboriginal health ||3.6 |
|Anaesthetics ||3.4 |
|Emergency medicine ||2.9 |
|Oncology ||2.6 |
|Mental health ||2.5 |
|Other ||2.5 |
|Surgery ||2.3 |
|General practitioner ||2.3 |
|Non-patient ||1.9 |
|Imaging and pathology ||1.6 |
|Paediatrics ||1.0 |
|Obstetrics and gynaecology ||0.8 |
|Mean ||2.5 |
Percentage of doctors by specialty who listed bullying as a source of stress
| Doctors by specialty ||% |
|Non-patient ||12.4 |
|Imaging and pathology ||6.0 |
|Oncology ||6.0 |
|Surgery ||5.5 |
|Obstetrics and gynaecology ||5.3 |
|Paediatrics ||5.3 |
|Other ||5.0 |
|Mental health ||4.8 |
|Rural/remote medicine or Aboriginal health ||4.1 |
|Emergency medicine ||3.8 |
|Anaesthetics ||3.7 |
|General practitioner ||3.2 |
|Mean ||4.5 |
- 58.6% of doctors agreed that being a patient causes embarrassment for a doctor
- 47.9% agreed that doctors are less likely to appoint doctors with a history of depression or an anxiety disorder
- 44.8% agreed that many doctors believe that experiencing depression or an anxiety disorder is a sign of personal weakness
- 40.2% agreed that many doctors think less of doctors who have experienced depression or an anxiety disorder.
Reasons doctors don't get help for anxiety or depression
- Fear of lack of confidentiality/privacy is the biggest barrier, with 52.5% doctors saying it is a barrier
- 37.4% said embarrassment is a barrier
- 34.3% said impact on registration and right to practice is a barrier.
- 43% of medical students have a high likelihood of experiencing a minor psychiatric disorder and 9.2% have very high levels of psychological distress. The general community mean score for high psychological distress is 2.6%
- 19.2%, including 31.8% of Indigenous medical students, have had suicidal thoughts in the past year
- 21.3% are moderate risk drinkers while a further 4% are high risk drinkers
- 52.3% are experiencing emotional exhaustion.
- Doctors aged 30 and under work the longest hours of any age group (49.8 hours a week compared to 43.6 mean)
- These doctors are the most likely of any age group to be probably experiencing a minor psychiatric disorder (36.7% compared to 27.2% mean) and are the most likely to be experiencing very high psychological distress (5.9% compared to mean of 3.4%). The general community mean score for high psychological distress is 2.6%
- These doctors are the most likely of any age group to have a current diagnosis of depression (10.4% compared to 6.2% mean) and are the most likely to have a current diagnosis of anxiety (4.9% compared to 3.7% mean)
- These doctors are the most likely of any age group to have had suicidal thoughts in the past year (12.7% compared to 10.4% mean) and score the highest on the three burnout factors of high emotional exhaustion, high cynicism and low professional efficacy
- Doctors who are at the intern or training stage rate similarly high on these measures.
- Approximately 0.2% of doctors who responded to the survey were Indigenous (this is a similar proportion to that reported in the 2011 census). As the sample size is small, results should be interpreted with caution.
- However 22% were considered to have a high likelihood of having a minor psychiatric disorder. 22% of doctors also reported being very stressed by bullying, which is higher than levels reported by the general survey population (4.4%).
- Approximately 1.2% of the student sample was Indigenous. 73% of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students were classified as having a high likelihood of a minor psychiatric disorder. While interpretation is limited by the sample size, this is a substantially higher proportion in comparison to non-Indigenous students (43%). 27% reported very high psychological distress, which is again higher than that reported by non-Indigenous students (9%).
- Doctors specialising in rural/remote/Aboriginal health work the longest hours (50.9 a week compared to 43.6 mean).
- These doctors are the specialists most likely to be high risk or harmful drinkers (3.6% compared to 2.5% mean), the most likely to be experiencing high emotional exhaustion (38.9% compared to 31.6% mean) and have the second highest cynicism levels (38.4% have high levels compared to 34.6% mean).
- Doctors in remote locations work the longest hours of any group by work area (46.2 hour a week compared to 43.6 mean)
- They are the most likely by work area to be experiencing a minor psychiatric disorder (31.0%) and are the most likely to be experiencing very high psychological distress (4.8% compared to the community mean score of 2.6%)
- They are the most likely by work area to have had suicidal thoughts in the past year (14.2% compared to 10.4% mean) and most likely to have ever attempted suicide (3.6% compared to 2.3% mean)
- They are the most likely by work area to be moderate risk drinkers (15.5% compared to 12.8% mean) and harmful or high-risk drinkers (6.2% compared to 2.5% mean).